So some of you followed my in-and-out love affair with a GS 2011 Ltd Fall Cocobolo .... and gave my some valuable advice, which I appreciate highly.
I ended up keeping and valuing the Coco for what it is. It definitely has its strengths and everyone who saw/played it liked it. I played it live twice and both times it was a reliable companion. But I know what sound / feeling I am after and that is not it... So the guitar is currently safe in its case and I will probably put it up for sale on a well known auction site soon.
Whilst I was looking for a replacement, I had an opportunity to play quite a few other guitars - some spoke to me and some not. Most notably I was expecting to fall in love with a 914 V-brace (which was offered at a good price), but did not see as all that special (tonally). Maybe it was just that particular example... The closest I got to was an 814 Dlx but it had a slight ding and the price was still quite high.
My search surprisingly led me onto a 2017 812CE 12-f dlx (x-braced). Having always played big guitars (GA-size and above), my initial impression was that this guitar looked like a toy with its short scale and shorter neck particularly. I was also a little hesitant as I had previously tried a V-braced 812CE 12 fret and felt its mids were way too dominant and its sound a bit boxy.
But this was one was different, maybe because of the X-brace, it felt more balanced across the EQ spectrum. One characteristic which I could immediately resonate with (pun intended) was how alive it felt. The whole thing just moved, shook and vibrated under my fingers - even with single notes runs. With chords - it was like a living thing. The other characteristic which I was really surprised about was how loud it was. I tried it side by side with my GS Coco, with a Martin OM-42 and with another 814 and this little thing projected volume in spades. Granted it was strung with some old strings, I thought - if it sounds this good now, it will sing with a new set, so I pulled the trigger.
I have since installed a new set of Santa Cruz Low Tension strings (I got the string tip from a video on YouTube by a guy playing the same model) and the guitar just sings - particularly finger picked. If I have to split hairs, the low E response is a little on the shallow side (more detectable when strumming) but that is to be expected to with a Grand Concert when comparing to a Grand Symphony. Finger picked it's much less discernible. Still, it is a musical bass, not a cheap-sounding bass. I am stoked with it. And it looks fantastic with the radius arm rest and a nicely figured fingerboard. This one is a keeper.
So there you have it - my journey from a GS to a GC 12f. Who would have thought!