Your tonal preference, of course. But given you're ordering this guitar and thus buying blind, I'd suggest the GA bod when talking about cedar/rw. I love GS guitars with certain woods (like maple or mahog b/s...I really dig those!). But all that bass, which is immediately impressive at the onset, starts to lose its appeal when you live with it for a bit; that bias toward the bottom means the upper mids take a backseat to the whole voice of the guitar. To me that is imbalanced overall tone.
To my taste, cedar has those glorious mids that is so warm with such a present "tenor voice" (for lack of a better term) that begs to be heard, and rw fills the bottom end so well with deep, resonant bass, the larger GS body detracts from the overall sonic impact of the guitar. I had only recently sold my long-time #1 which was my beloved GA7e ...but that wood combo still sits prominantly in my head that I hope I can replace that tone back in the stable in the future. Just so well balanced; all tones present and accounted for; all playing together well. Not so much with the 716. And of course, all IMHO so no offense to any 716 owners (or GS8/816 of which I feel the same way).
Edward