I've been wanting a larger body guitar for my collection and was really interested in taking a serious look at either a new re-voiced 618 or 616. I convinced myself that the 616 might be similar to my 814 and 812 so I was leaning more towards the 618. In the process I visited a local GC where I had played an HD-28 and a Gibson SJ-100 and liked both guitars. On my second visit, I tried a Gibson J-45 but it did not move me. While noodling around with a new HD-28, the salesman showed me a mint 2013 HD-35 and it had more brightness and clarity than the HD-28 while still retaining most of the low end. I went home with the HD-35 at a price that was several hundred less than a new D-28 so I feel like I got a great deal.
It's been interesting how the HD-35 compares to my Taylors. Surprisingly it does everything well but I think it excels at flat-picking so far. It does strum a bit louder and you can drive it a bit harder than my 814 but I don't believe I have the best string set on it currently. The tone is different also but nice. It's not whether one is better than the other, just a different sound. Owning an iconic Martin model is pretty cool.