It's about another summary time!
I combined Michael's list together (thanks, Michael!) and marked the shops that got recommendations from multiple members with asterisk:
Gryphon Stringed Instruments, Palo Alto, CA
Guitar Trader / Music Power, San Diego, CA
Rick's Guitar Shop, San Diego, CA
Guitar Showcase, San Jose, CA
McCabe's Guitar Shop, Santa Monica, CA
LA Guitar Sales, West Hollywood, CA
Spotlight Music, Ft. Collins, CO
Wildwood Guitars, Louisville, CO
My Favorite Guitars, Naples, FL
Maple Street Guitars, Atlanta, GA
Ken Stanton Music, Atlanta, GA
Scotty's Music, Kalaheo, HI
The Player's Bench, Crystal Lake, IL
Tobias Music, Downer's Grove, IL
Wilcutt Guitars, Lexington, KY
Appalachian Bluegrass Shoppe, Catonsville, MD
Chuck Levin's Washington Music Center, Wheaton, MD*
Elderly Instruments, Lansing, MI
Guitar Rodeo, Minneapolis, MN
The Podium, Minneapolis, MN*
Willie's American Guitars, St.Paul, MN
Music Villa, Bozeman, MT
Legacy Music, Lees Summit, MO
Fazio's Frets & Friends, St. Louis, MO*
Music Folk, St. Louis, MO
Magnolia Music Center, Gulfport & Ocean Springs, MS
Fat Sound Guitars, Cary, NC
Holloway's Music Center, Monroe, NC
Harry's Guitar Shop, Raleigh, NC*
Alto Music, Wappingers Falls, NY
Wildwood Music, Coshocton, OH
The Drinking Gourd, Dayton, OH
Uptown Music, Keizer, OR
Cintioli Music, Philadelphia, PA
Empire Music, Pittsburgh, PA
Pianos N Stuff, Pittsburgh, PA
Woody's Music, Rock Hill, SC
Martin Music, Memphis, TN
Gruhn Guitars, Nashville, TN
Grapevine Guitar Works, Grapevine, TX
Melodee Music, Leesburg & Sterling, VA*
Dusty Strings, Seattle, WA
Dave's, LaCrosse, WI
The 12th Fret, Toronto, Canada
Total 44 FLGSs.
Thank you folks. Hope we get more!